Free Consultation 1-800-499-9902


Supreme Court Justices Say Criminal Justice System is Faulty

Posted by Seth Chazin | May 27, 2015 | 0 Comments

Supreme Court Justices Stephen Breyer and Anthony Kennedy told a House subcommittee that the current justice system in place in America is too harsh. They believe that it locks up too many people for too long and does so at an ultimate cost of public safety.

Justice Kennedy believes that it would be more effective if we put offenders on probation and other supervised release programs. He stated, “The idea of total incarceration is just not working.” He believes that probation is a better option and more efficient because those offenders who are already released into the community have a very low rate of recidivism.

Justice Breyer, along with Kennedy, said that setting mandatory minimum sentences was generally “a terrible idea.” He called upon Congress to make it a priority to improve the criminal justice system.

Republicans and Democrats used this opportunity to ask the justices questions which had little to do with $88 million fiscal budget request.  For example, Rep. Steve Womack(R., Ark.) said he wanted the views of the justices on  prison and local jail overcrowding. He had spoken to local officials in his district and believes that the jails and prisons you cannot accommodate all inmates sentenced to incarceration. Justice Kennedy agreed that the corrections system is one of the most overlooked institutions we have in our government. Kennedy usually sides with law enforcement in criminal cases, but he has joined the Court's liberals to hold that prison overcrowding is a significant problem and can become so severe as to violate the 8th amendment prohibition against “cruel and unusual punishment.”

Justice Kennedy stated that California has more than 150,000 people who are incarcerated, costing the state $30,000 per inmate, compared to the $3,500 per year given to each California pupil enrolled  in school. Justice Kennedy is also very concerned with the use of solitary confinement. Studies have shown that European justice systems confine prisoners in groups of three or four, with better results. Justice Kennedy calls for more research into effective methods of incarceration. “We haven't given it nearly enough study, nearly enough thought,” Justice Kennedy said.

Read More:

Wall Street Journal: Two Supreme Court Justices Say Criminal Justice System Isn't Working 

About the Author

Seth Chazin

Seth P. Chazin has aggressively defended clients in thousands of felony and misdemeanor cases for over 30 years. He has extensive experience representing criminal defendants in federal and state court, while handling both state and federal appeals as well.


There are no comments for this post. Be the first and Add your Comment below.

Leave a Comment


“The death penalty is a lie, a misguided mistake born of anger and frustration. Capital punishment has become a perverse monument to inequality, to how some lives matter and others do not. It is a violent example of how we protect and value the rich and abandon and devalue the poor. The death penalty is a grim, disturbing shadow formed by the legacy of racial apartheid and bias against the poor that condemns the disfavored among us, but corrupts us all. It’s the perverse symbol elected officials use to strengthen their ‘tough on crime’ reputations and distract us from confronting the causes of violence. It is finally the enemy of grace, redemption and all of us who recognize that each person is more than their worse act.”
- Bryan Stevenson